Top 15 cigars of 2011


It’s that time of year again to weigh in with my opinion of the top cigars of the previous year. There are a few surprises, but many of them made some other lists as well. It’s been a fun 3 years at and I really look forward to sharing my year end list. But as always, I invite you to smoke as many releases as possible and formulate your own opinion. After all, we know what they say about opinions..

15. Cro-Magnon – I love it when a little guy, makes his mark on the world. In the world of cigars Skip Martin and Michael Rosales team up to give us the  Cro-Magnon and this full bodied smoke really delivered. It will put hair on your chest and turn you into a caveman if you aren’t careful.

14. Quesada Espana – This stick was created for the Spanish market, but it was met with great fanfare from the online community which forced the hand of Matasa to release this stateside. The sticks are available in a limited amount of stores so tracking them down can be difficult, but they are worth the effort.

13. Room 101 Namakubi – I had been disappointed with Room 101 and the releases they put out, but the Namakubi really changed things up for me as a consumer.  Namakubi turned out to be everything Room 101 wasn’t and brought forth a renewed interest in the brand.

12. EP Carrillo New Wave ConnecticutIn any other year this smoke could of been a top 3 cigar. The EP Carrillo New Wave Connecticut might be the best Connecticut shade to ever grace the marketplace. Mild in strength but with a complex profile this cigar should be around for many years to come.

11. Casa Magna Dominus Magnus – Hanging out in Tobacco Plaza in Long Island, Pete Johnson told Manuel Quesada that he was crazy for making this a limited edition cigar and that it should be a regular release. Sadly, lack of tobacco prevented that from happening. A box pressed treasure is the best way to describe this smoke.

10. Jamie Garcia Limited Edition 2011 – At the Big Smoke in NYC I was in awe when Jaime Garcia recognized me with a salute through the crowd and was blown away when he stopped to talk to me with his wife. It’s good to see Jaime embracing the English language and I hope to have another conversation with him in the future when he realizes his English is better than he thinks.

09. Emilio AF 1 – The brand from Gary Griffith is a cigar that most people don’t know is around. This is a shame, as it is an epic cigar. Flavor, balanced and priced right this cigar should become the new wave of boutique cigars that will have everyone clamoring for more.

08. Undercrown – The latest from Drew Estate hopes to fill in the void for those who can’t get the Liga Privada No. 9. Full strength, and a nice profile the cigar delivers better then expected. Just be sure to smoke in a well ventilated area as this cigar produces some amazing volumes of smoke.

07. Fausto – Billed as a cigar where the strength goes to 11, I tend to disagree with it. It was also billed as being based on the same blend as the T110 and I tend to disagree with that. What I do agree with is that this smoke was a top 10 cigar for 2011, so the first two points are moot.

06. Illusione 88 Candela -Most Candela cigars that have been on the market since I began smoking in 1999 have been awful. In fact, I can’t think of one I would smoke again. That is until now. The Illusione Candela is a great cigar, and easily the best Candela ever made.

05. Litto Gomez Small Batch #4 – The small batch #4 forced me to rewrite my list, this cigar uses a Pelo de Oro wrapper and is a flavor bomb, the price however is a bit much in the New York market which kept it from ranking a bit higher.

04. San Lotano Oval – Made by AJ Fernandez the San Lotano Oval is an oval pressed cigar. It feels perfect in the hand with a nice profile and a good price. Remember the name, AJ Fernandez as I predict he will be a house hold name in the cigar industry within a couple of years.

03. Casa MirandaMiami Cigar & Company stepped outside their relationship with My Father Cigars to release the Casa Miranda. Made in Miami by Titan de Bronze in Calle Ocho the stick is labeled Chapter One, so you have to wonder when Chapter Two will be on the market.

02. Four Kicks – I toyed around with naming this cigar, cigar of the year but in the end it comes in as #2. Made by EP Carrillo for Crowned Heads this stick was the first released from Jon Huber and the former CAO gang. Currently limited to 66 stores, the smoke should be a wider release next year.

01. La Casita Criolla – This pick is sure to get a lot of feedback. Within my circle of friends this cigar might be the most polarizing stick on the market. In fact, Pete mentioned a friend of mine texting him how much he disliked the smoke when it first came out on Stogie 411. For me however, this Connecticut Broadleaf Puro is so different than anything currently on the market that it keeps calling me back again and again.


You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.
  • David Jones

    Interesting list…I agree to some degree and you will definitely see some of the same cigars on my list in about a week.

  • Dan

    Good list Barry

  • Jon Huber

    Barry – It was an honor to even be ‘considered,’ let alone come in at #2(!)…considering we shipped our first cigars out about 6 weeks ago, I’m very proud of what our team has accomplished this year.

    I’ve been a fan of what Pete’s been doing since he handed me an unbanded Tatuaje on the RTDA floor back in 2003.  I was amazed back then and continue to be today.  So it’s somewhat surreal to even be mentioned in the same list.I also see that there are a lot of cigars I need to seek out and enjoy–it truly /is/ a great time to be a cigar smoker…so much quality product coming out these days.Cheers & Happy Holidays to All.Jon HuberCrowned Heads

  • b.stone

    Good List and totally agree with the LCC as #1 but the Tat TAA makes my list as well.

  • Cj

    As always, I enjoy reading your list for the year.  Hopefully, PJ gets wind of it and takes a look.  I finished a box of La Casita Criolla a few weeks back.  I love the unique flavor as well, but most…at least half in the box were plugged and produced almost no smoke.  I was so let down, not only by expecting what I experienced when trying a few sticks…but more so by the hype and nobody mentions problems with the sticks.  My box price was very expensive when considering how many in it burned so poorly.  The magic did shine through on the few that were rolled with some quality in mind, but I would hesitate to buy the brand again at this point.  Please everyone, don’t tell me to rest the darn things, because other brands have it figured out.  I will certainly seek out the four kicks as well as some others.  I would have put the LFD Colorado Oscuro in there….classic flavors and smokes great!

    Merry Christmas everyone!

  • Skip

    Great list Barry. thanks for recognizing the CroMagnon.

    More to come next year!


  • CigarCraig

    If I were to post a Top Whatever list, the Cro Magnon, Emilio and La Casita would be on it. I adore the  La Casita and may just smoke one tonight. 

  • David Jones

    I noticed poor burns on a few of my LCCs, too, and I have a guess as to what causes it. Since the entire cigar is composed of Broadleaf, it is a very “wet” stick. The higher the moisture content the harder it is to draw through. I think dry-boxing (leaving the cigar to sit for a couple hours up to a day or two outside the humidor) might fix the issue. Or simply storing this blend at a lower humidification level. I also avoid the smallest ring gauge vitola of the LCC because it tends to be more problematic for me.

  • smoke770

    nice list! Happy Hanukah!

  • JoshK

    Interesting list. Apparently I missed out on a lot of cigars this year because I don’t even recognize 1/2 of these

  • Jason-HLCigars

    Nice list.  The Casita is doing really well on everyone’s list.  I need to smoke a few more of these.

  • Anonymous

    Finally a real list, made up of great cigars, unlike that other touted list by a big magazine that is full of labels with over inflated ratings all driven by advertising dollars.  

  • TriMarkC

    Well, I’ve tried only two from the list, so I have my early 2012 Cigar Bucket List! Thanks!

  • acigarsmoker

    What are you waiting for? It’s already February and we have many more great sticks coming in our reviews!



  • irratebass

    Have only had the Undercrown in this list….I need to get smoking, although I do have an EP Carillo NWC resting in my humi.

  • Dan

    Love the Casa Magna and the Undercrown 

  • Roscoe

    Thanks for the rankings!!  Now I have a nice list of cigars to try and I’ll let you know if I agree with the list – I just hope I can find most of them…

  • TriMarkC

    Waiting for??  After what I spent at Christmas for cigars, my wife is watching every penny I spend …. STILL!  :-P

  • TriMarkC

    Did I read recently that the CroMagnons are in short supply due to wrapper supplies??

Powered by WordPress | Designed by: video game | Thanks to seo services, seo service and Etiketten drucken